Every trading strategy ends with the same small print: past performance is no guarantee of future results. Almost nobody checks the past performance either. That is what we do.
We take strategies that people share, sell and swear by, from YouTube and X to trading forums and academic papers. We rebuild each one from its published rules and run it through the tests its author usually skipped. We test market rules of thumb and published research claims the same way.
What every strategy goes through
Real costs. Commissions, slippage and the delay between a signal and a fill.
The whole account. What a real account earns against simply holding the index, not just the average trade.
Years it has never seen. Out-of-sample data and neighbouring settings, so a lucky parameter cannot pass.
A normal life. Could someone with a day job and a broker account actually run it?
How we test. The method, step by step.
What you get
An honest verdict you can use: what holds up, what does not, and what survives with a fix. When a strategy fails, we say so, even when it is one we run in our own paper account. When one passes, we show exactly how it works.
What we have found so far. No strategy has yet cleanly beaten holding the index. A few came close, and each one taught us a check worth keeping.
One issue every Tuesday at 07:00 New York time, free. New here? Start with every verdict so far.
Send us a strategy
Found something on X or YouTube that looks too good to be true? Reply to any issue, leave a comment, or write to [email protected] with a link to the rules or the video. We test the strongest and publish what we find.
Our rules
We name and link every author and lead with what replicated. Authors get a right of reply before we publish. When a published number turns out wrong, we fix it in the open, with a dated note. We sell no signals.
— Antoni Gaudi, Past Performance Lab
Disclaimer
Past Performance Lab discusses how trading strategies behaved on historical data. It is not a financial advisory service, and the author is not a licensed financial adviser. Nothing here is a recommendation to buy, sell or hold any security or to follow any strategy, and nothing is tailored to any reader's circumstances. When we test a strategy a reader sends us, we publish the result for everyone; we do not answer individual investment questions. We accept no payment from the authors or products we test. Backtested results are hypothetical, and readers should not rely on this publication in making an investment decision.

