Start here · updated 12 November 2026
Past Performance Lab checks trading strategies before you risk money on them. We rebuild each strategy from its author's own rules. Then we test it the way your account would live it.
That means three things. Every trade pays trading costs. Money waiting out of the market earns only Treasury bill interest. And the result is compared with simply holding the index, through one fund such as QQQ or SPY.
What we keep finding
Many strategies have a real strength, such as a high win rate or a smaller worst fall. Then we count what the account made. A strategy that waits in cash most days misses much of the market's growth. So far, none has cleanly beaten simply holding the index.
Every test is on the Scoreboard, one block per strategy: the claim, our result, the index, the verdict.
How to read a verdict
Fails: no real profit after trading costs.
Loses to the index: the edge is real, but the account ends behind simply holding the index.
Unproven: the data cannot yet tell a real edge from luck or tuning.
Replicates: the author's own claim checks out on our data. That alone says nothing about the index.
Works as an add-on: weak alone, but it helped when kept on top of an index holding. We say how strong the evidence is.
Each block also answers one question: should you use it? The answer is No, Only as an add-on, or Maybe. Issues that study data rather than a strategy say so.
Three issues to read first
Nine Wins in Ten, a Quarter of the Money (Issue 10). The plainest example of winning trades that still lose money. It opens with a 60-second verdict.
The Missing Ten Weeks (Issue 03). A 95% win rate that is real, and a start date that hides the risk. Read it before you trust a short backtest.
The 47-Second Tax (Issue 07). Real orders fill later than a backtest assumes. This issue measures what the wait costs.
Where to go next
The Scoreboard: every verdict so far, newest first.
How We Test a Trading Strategy: the checks every strategy goes through, and what each verdict means.
About: who we are, and the full disclaimer.
Your turn
Send us the strategy you are about to risk money on. Write to [email protected].
Full method: How We Test a Trading Strategy.
Past performance is no guarantee of future results. We check anyway.
This is research on historical data, not investment advice. Full disclaimer.

